What happens with an Unsatisfactory safety rating?
Short answer
A proposed Unsatisfactory rating is FMCSA's preliminary finding that you are unfit. Unless you fix things in time, you may not operate from day 46 after the notice if you haul passengers or placarded hazmat, or from day 61 for other carriers. FMCSA then issues an out-of-service order and revokes your operating authority.
A proposed Unsatisfactory rating is the one rating with a built-in shutdown date. Under 49 CFR 385.11(d), it is notice that FMCSA has made a preliminary determination that you are "unfit," and that the 385.13 prohibitions will apply unless you make the necessary improvements in time.
The clock
| Passenger or placarded hazmat carrier | Other carriers | |
|---|---|---|
| Proposed rating becomes final | 45 days after the notice | 60 days after the notice |
| Prohibited from operating CMVs | From day 46 | From day 61 |
| Extension possible? | No. Filing an upgrade request doesn't stay the 45 days (385.17(f)). | Up to 60 more days if FMCSA finds a good-faith effort (385.13(a)(2), 385.17(g)) |
| FMCSA must decide an upgrade request within | 30 days | 45 days |
| Ask for an administrative review by | Day 15 to get a decision before the ban; 90 days at the latest (385.15(c)) | |
Count the days from the date on the notice, not from the date you received it.
If it becomes final
- Out-of-service order. FMCSA orders your operations out of service, covering both interstate operations and operations affecting interstate commerce (385.13(d)(1)).
- Revocation of operating authority. After notice, FMCSA revokes your operating authority registration (385.13(e)).
- Federal work. Federal agencies may not use a carrier rated Unsatisfactory (385.13(b)–(c)).
- Hazmat permit. A safety permit requires Satisfactory (385.407), so it's gone too.
Current penalties for operating anyway
| Carrier | Maximum civil penalty |
|---|---|
| Most carriers, operating after a final Unsatisfactory rating | $34,116 per offense. Each day is a separate offense. |
| Carriers of placarded hazardous materials | $102,348 per offense. Up to $238,809 if death, serious illness, severe injury or substantial property destruction results. |
49 CFR Part 386, Appendix B, paragraph (f), as amended through 91 FR 45660 (July 21, 2026). More amounts in FMCSA civil penalties.
What to do in the first two weeks
- Read the deficiency list in the notice and match every item to a regulation cite.
- Decide whether any finding is factually wrong. If one is, prepare an administrative review and file it within 15 days.
- Start fixing what's real right away, and document each fix as you go. The upgrade request under 385.17 is built from those records.
- File the upgrade request early enough for FMCSA's 30 or 45-day review to finish before your day 46 or day 61.
- With this much at stake, involve a transportation attorney. Part 385 doesn't require one, but the consequences are severe.
RatingFix's kit is built for Conditional ratings. With a proposed Unsatisfactory, use it only alongside qualified advice.
Related questions
Can I get more time on a proposed Unsatisfactory rating?
Property carriers that don't haul placarded hazmat may get up to 60 more days if FMCSA finds a good-faith effort to improve (49 CFR 385.13(a)(2), 385.17(g)). Passenger and placarded hazmat carriers get no extension.
How fast do I need to ask for an administrative review?
Within 15 days of the proposed Unsatisfactory notice, if you want a decision before the prohibition takes effect (49 CFR 385.15(c)(1)). The outer limit is 90 days.
What is the penalty for operating after a final Unsatisfactory rating?
Up to $34,116 per offense for most carriers, with each day a separate offense. For placarded hazmat carriers it is up to $102,348, rising to $238,809 if death or serious injury results (49 CFR Part 386, Appendix B (f)).
Rated Conditional? See what each violation needs, free
Type your USDOT number and add the violations from your review. RatingFix shows how each one was scored and what FMCSA needs to see fixed. The full upgrade kit (385.17 request letter, corrective action plan, evidence checklist, policies and filing guide) is $499 if you want it.
Next questions
- How long does it take FMCSA to upgrade a safety rating?
- Should I appeal my safety rating or ask for an upgrade?
- How much are FMCSA fines?
- How to upgrade a Conditional DOT safety rating