How long does it take FMCSA to upgrade a safety rating?
Short answer
For a proposed or final Unsatisfactory rating, FMCSA must decide an upgrade request within 30 days for passenger and placarded hazmat carriers and within 45 days for everyone else (49 CFR 385.17(e)). Part 385 sets no deadline for a Conditional upgrade, so the time depends on FMCSA's workload and how complete your request is.
"How long does it take?" is the most common question after a review. Part 385 answers part of it with hard deadlines. For the rest, it sets no deadline at all.
Every deadline in Part 385, in one table
| Step | Passenger or placarded hazmat carrier | All other carriers | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rating notice after the compliance review | No later than 30 days after the review | 385.9(b), 385.11(a) | |
| Proposed rating becomes final | 45 days after the notice | 60 days after the notice | 385.11(c) |
| Satisfactory, or an improvement from Unsatisfactory | Final on the date of the notice | 385.11(b) | |
| Proposed Unsatisfactory: operating ban starts | Day 46 | Day 61 (up to 60 more days for a good-faith effort) | 385.13(a), 385.17(g) |
| FMCSA decides an upgrade request on an Unsatisfactory | Within 30 days of the request | Within 45 days of the request | 385.17(e) |
| FMCSA decides an upgrade request on a Conditional | No deadline in the rule | 385.17 | |
| Ask for an administrative review | Within 90 days of the rating or of an upgrade denial (15 days to beat a proposed Unsatisfactory) | 385.15(c) | |
| FMCSA decides an administrative review of an Unsatisfactory | 30 days | 45 days | 385.15(e) |
Why Conditional has no clock
The 30 and 45-day review periods in 385.17(e) exist because an Unsatisfactory rating shuts a carrier down. A Conditional rating doesn't, so the rule leaves the timing to FMCSA. FMCSA doesn't publish a typical turnaround either, so treat any number you see quoted, including on consultants' sites, as anecdotal.
What you control
- When you file. 385.17(a) lets you request a change "at any time," even while the rating is still proposed. You don't have to wait for a proposed rating to become final before asking for a change.
- Completeness. FMCSA decides on the documents you submit plus any other relevant information (385.17(d)). Every cited violation should have a written corrective action and proof. A request with gaps invites follow-up questions or a denial.
- Where it goes. Send it to the Service Center for your principal place of business (385.17(b), 390.27). A request sent to the wrong office starts in the wrong queue.
After FMCSA decides
If FMCSA finds the corrective actions done and your operations now meet 385.5 and 385.7, it notifies you in writing of the upgraded rating (385.17(h)), and SAFER changes. If not, you get a written denial (385.17(i)). You then have 90 days to ask for an administrative review, or you can fix the gaps and file again.
Related questions
How long after a compliance review do I get my rating?
FMCSA must send written notice within 30 days of the review (49 CFR 385.9(b), 385.11(a)).
When does a proposed rating become final?
A Satisfactory rating, or one that improves an Unsatisfactory, is final on the date of the notice. Any other proposed rating becomes final after 45 days for passenger and placarded hazmat carriers and 60 days for others (49 CFR 385.11(b)–(c)).
Does filing an upgrade request stop the clock on an Unsatisfactory rating?
Not for passenger or placarded hazmat carriers. 49 CFR 385.17(f) says the request does not stay their 45-day period. Other carriers may get up to 60 more days if FMCSA finds a good-faith effort (385.17(g)).
Rated Conditional? See what each violation needs, free
Type your USDOT number and add the violations from your review. RatingFix shows how each one was scored and what FMCSA needs to see fixed. The full upgrade kit (385.17 request letter, corrective action plan, evidence checklist, policies and filing guide) is $499 if you want it.
Next questions
- How to upgrade a Conditional DOT safety rating
- What happens with an Unsatisfactory safety rating?
- Should I appeal my safety rating or ask for an upgrade?