Acute and critical violations, and how they set your rating
Short answer
An acute violation counts against your rating the first time it is found. A critical violation counts only as a pattern: more than one, and at least 10% of the records checked. Each one is a point in its rating factor, and the factor ratings go into Appendix B's table to give your overall safety rating.
After a compliance review, FMCSA rates a carrier using the method in Appendix B to 49 CFR Part 385. Violations of certain regulations count toward the rating: acute regulations count on a single violation, critical regulations count when there is a pattern.
Acute vs critical
- Acute regulations are those where noncompliance is so severe it requires immediate corrective action regardless of the overall safety posture. One violation counts.
- Critical regulations relate to management or operational controls that indicate breakdowns in a carrier's controls. They count when there is a pattern: more than one violation, and the number found is at least 10% of the records checked.
Points and factors
Appendix B groups the regulations into six rating factors:
| Factor | Covers |
|---|---|
| 1 · General | Parts 387 and 390 |
| 2 · Driver | Parts 382, 383 and 391 |
| 3 · Operational | Parts 392 and 395 |
| 4 · Vehicle | Parts 393 and 396 |
| 5 · Hazardous Materials | Parts 397, 171, 177 and 180 (Parts 172 and 173 are also listed in Appendix B, II(f)) |
| 6 · Accident | Recordable accident rate |
Each acute violation, and each critical pattern, is one point in its factor. A pattern of critical violations of Part 395 (hours of service) is two points. Within each factor:
| Points in the factor | Factor rating |
|---|---|
| 0 | Satisfactory |
| 1 | Conditional |
| 2 or more | Unsatisfactory |
The Accident factor (6) is rated from the carrier's recordable accident rate, not violation points.
From factor ratings to your safety rating
| Unsatisfactory factors | Conditional factors | Safety rating |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 2 or fewer | Satisfactory |
| 0 | more than 2 | Conditional |
| 1 | 2 or fewer | Conditional |
| 1 | more than 2 | Unsatisfactory |
| 2 or more | 0 or more | Unsatisfactory |
What this means for an upgrade
Every acute violation and critical pattern that pushed a factor to Conditional or Unsatisfactory is what your upgrade request has to answer, with a corrective action and evidence for each. Violations not on the list don't add points, but they were still found; fixing them strengthens the request.
The full list (Appendix B, section VII)
110 regulations: 43 acute, 67 critical. Descriptions as published.
| § | Violation | Type |
|---|---|---|
| 382.115(a) | Failing to implement an alcohol and/or controlled substances testing program (domestic motor carrier) | Acute |
| 382.115(b) | Failing to implement an alcohol and/or controlled substances testing program (foreign motor carrier) | Acute |
| 382.201 | Using a driver known to have an alcohol concentration of 0.04 or greater | Acute |
| 382.211 | Using a driver who has refused to submit to an alcohol or controlled substances test required under part 382 | Acute |
| 382.213(c) | Using a driver known to have used a controlled substance | Acute |
| 382.215 | Using a driver known to have tested positive for a controlled substance | Acute |
| 382.301(a) | Using a driver before the motor carrier has received a negative pre-employment controlled substance test result | Critical |
| 382.303(a) | Failing to conduct post accident testing on driver for alcohol | Critical |
| 382.303(b) | Failing to conduct post accident testing on driver for controlled substances | Critical |
| 382.305(a) | Failing to implement a random controlled substances and/or an alcohol testing program | Acute |
| 382.305(b)(1) | Failing to conduct random alcohol testing at an annual rate of not less than the applicable annual rate of the average number of driver positions | Critical |
| 382.305(b)(2) | Failing to conduct random controlled substances testing at an annual rate of not less than the applicable annual rate of the average number of driver positions | Critical |
| 382.309 | Using a driver who has not undergone return-to-duty testing with a negative drug test result and/or an alcohol test with an alcohol concentration of less than 0.02 in accordance with 49 CFR 40.305 | Acute |
| 382.503 | Allowing a driver to perform safety sensitive function, after engaging in conduct prohibited by subpart B, without being evaluated by substance abuse professional, as required by § 382.605 | Critical |
| 382.505(a) | Using a driver within 24 hours after being found to have an alcohol concentration of 0.02 or greater but less than 0.04 | Acute |
| 382.605 | Failing to subject a driver who has been identified as needing assistance to at least six unannounced follow-up drug and/or alcohol tests in the first 12 months following the driver's return-to-duty in accordance with 49 CFR 40.307 | Critical |
| 383.23(a) | Operating a commercial motor vehicle without a valid commercial driver's license | Critical |
| 383.37(a) | Allowing, requiring, permitting, or authorizing a driver to operate a CMV who the employer knew or should reasonably have known does not have a current CLP or CDL, does not have a CLP or CDL with the proper class or endorsements, or operates a CMV in violation of any restriction on the CLP or CDL | Acute |
| 383.37(b) | Allowing, requiring, permitting, or authorizing a driver to operate a CMV who the employer knew or should reasonably have known has a CLP or CDL disqualified by a State, has lost the right to operate a CMV in a State, or has been disqualified | Acute |
| 383.37(c) | Allowing, requiring, permitting, or authorizing a driver to operate a CMV who the employer knew or should reasonably have known has more than one CLP or CDL | Acute |
| 383.51(a) | Knowingly allowing, requiring, permitting, or authorizing a driver to drive who is disqualified to drive a commercial motor vehicle | Acute |
| 387.7(a) | Operating a motor vehicle without having in effect the required minimum levels of financial responsibility coverage | Acute |
| 387.7(d) | Failing to maintain at principal place of business required proof of financial responsibility | Critical |
| 387.31(a) | Operating a passenger carrying vehicle without having in effect the required minimum levels of financial responsibility | Acute |
| 387.31(d) | Failing to maintain at principal place of business required proof of financial responsibility for passenger carrying vehicles | Critical |
| 390.15(b)(2) | Failing to maintain copies of all accident reports required by State or other governmental entities or insurers | Critical |
| 390.35 | Making, or causing to make fraudulent or intentionally false statements or records and/or reproducing fraudulent records | Acute |
| 391.11(b)(4) | Using a physically unqualified driver | Acute |
| 391.15(a) | Using a disqualified driver | Acute |
| 391.45(a) | Using a driver not medically examined and certified | Critical |
| 391.45(b) | Using a driver not medically examined and certified during the preceding 24 months | Critical |
| 391.51(a) | Failing to maintain driver qualification file on each driver employed | Critical |
| 391.51(b)(2) | Failing to maintain inquiries into driver's driving record in driver's qualification file | Critical |
| 391.51(b)(6) | Failing to maintain medical examiner's certificate in driver's qualification file | Critical |
| 392.2 | Operating a motor vehicle not in accordance with the laws, ordinances, and regulations of the jurisdiction in which it is being operated | Critical |
| 392.4(b) | Requiring or permitting a driver to drive while under the influence of, or in possession of, a narcotic drug, amphetamine, or any other substance capable of rendering the driver incapable of safely operating a motor vehicle | Acute |
| 392.5(b)(1) | Requiring or permitting a driver to drive a motor vehicle while under the influence of, or in possession of, an intoxicating beverage | Acute |
| 392.5(b)(2) | Requiring or permitting a driver who shows evidence of having consumed an intoxicating beverage within 4 hours to operate a motor vehicle | Acute |
| 392.6 | Scheduling a run which would necessitate the vehicle being operated at speeds in excess of those prescribed | Critical |
| 392.9(a)(1) | Requiring or permitting a driver to drive without the vehicle's cargo being properly distributed and adequately secured | Critical |
| 395.1(h)(1)(i)(A) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive more than 15 hours (Driving in Alaska) | Critical |
| 395.1(h)(1)(i)(B) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty 20 hours (Driving in Alaska) | Critical |
| 395.1(h)(1)(i)(C) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty more than 70 hours in 7 consecutive days (Driving in Alaska) | Critical |
| 395.1(h)(1)(i)(D) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty more than 80 hours in 8 consecutive days (Driving in Alaska) | Critical |
| 395.1(h)(2)(i) | Requiring or permitting a passenger-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive more than 15 hours (Driving in Alaska) | Critical |
| 395.1(h)(2)(ii) | Requiring or permitting a passenger-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty 20 hours (Driving in Alaska) | Critical |
| 395.1(h)(2)(iii) | Requiring or permitting a passenger-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty more than 70 hours in 7 consecutive days (Driving in Alaska) | Critical |
| 395.1(h)(2)(iv) | Requiring or permitting a passenger-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty more than 80 hours in 8 consecutive days (Driving in Alaska) | Critical |
| 395.1(o) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty 16 consecutive hours | Critical |
| 395.3(a)(1) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive without taking an off-duty period of at least 10 consecutive hours prior to driving | Critical |
| 395.3(a)(2) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after the end of the 14th hour after coming on duty | Critical |
| 395.3(a)(3)(i) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive more than 11 hours | Critical |
| 395.3(a)(3)(ii) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive if more than 8 hours of driving time have passed without a consecutive interruption in driving status of at least 30 minutes, either off-duty, sleeper berth or on-duty not driving | Critical |
| 395.3(b)(1) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty more than 60 hours in 7 consecutive days | Critical |
| 395.3(b)(2) | Requiring or permitting a property-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty more than 70 hours in 8 consecutive days | Critical |
| 395.5(a)(1) | Requiring or permitting a passenger-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive more than 10 hours | Critical |
| 395.5(a)(2) | Requiring or permitting a passenger-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty 15 hours | Critical |
| 395.5(b)(1) | Requiring or permitting a passenger-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty more than 60 hours in 7 consecutive days | Critical |
| 395.5(b)(2) | Requiring or permitting a passenger-carrying commercial motor vehicle driver to drive after having been on duty more than 70 hours in 8 consecutive days | Critical |
| 395.8(a)(1) | Failing to require a driver to prepare a record of duty status using appropriate method | Critical |
| 395.8(a)(2)(ii) | Failure to require a driver to submit record of duty status | Critical |
| 395.8(e)(1) | Making, or permitting a driver to make, a false report regarding duty status | Critical |
| 395.8(e)(2)or(3) | Disabling, deactivating, disengaging, jamming, or otherwise blocking or degrading a signal transmission or reception; tampering with an automatic on-board recording device or ELD; or permitting or requiring another person to engage in such activity | Acute |
| 395.8(k)(1) | Failing to preserve a driver's record of duty status or supporting documents for 6 months | Critical |
| 395.11(b) | Failing to require a driver to submit supporting documents | Critical |
| 395.11(c) | Failing to retain types of supporting documents as required by § 395.11(c) | Critical |
| 395.11(e) | Failing to retain supporting documents in a manner that permits the effective matching of the documents to the driver's record of duty status | Critical |
| 395.11(f) | Altering, defacing, destroying, mutilating, or obscuring a supporting document | Critical |
| 395.30(f) | Failing to retain ELD information | Acute |
| 396.3(b) | Failing to keep minimum records of inspection and vehicle maintenance | Critical |
| 396.9(c)(2) | Requiring or permitting the operation of a motor vehicle declared “out-of-service” before repairs were made | Acute |
| 396.11(a) | Failing to require driver to prepare driver vehicle inspection report | Critical |
| 396.11(a)(3) | Failing to correct Out-of-Service defects listed by driver in a driver vehicle inspection report before the vehicle is operated again | Acute |
| 396.17(a) | Using a commercial motor vehicle not periodically inspected | Critical |
| 396.17(g) | Failing to promptly repair parts and accessories not meeting minimum periodic inspection standards | Acute |
| 397.5(a) | Failing to ensure a motor vehicle containing Division 1.1, 1.2, or 1.3 (explosive) material is attended at all times by its driver or a qualified representative | Acute |
| 397.7(a)(1) | Parking a motor vehicle containing Division 1.1, 1.2, or 1.3 materials within 5 feet of traveled portion of highway or street | Critical |
| 397.7(b) | Parking a motor vehicle containing hazardous material(s) other than Division 1.1, 1.2, or 1.3 materials within 5 feet of traveled portion of highway or street | Critical |
| 397.13(a) | Permitting a person to smoke or carry a lighted cigarette, cigar or pipe within 25 feet of a motor vehicle containing Class 1 materials, Class 5 materials, or flammable materials classified as Division 2.1, Class 3, Divisions 4.1 and 4.2 | Critical |
| 397.19(a) | Failing to furnish driver of motor vehicle transporting Division 1.1, 1.2, or 1.3 (explosive) materials with a copy of the rules of part 397 and/or emergency response instructions | Critical |
| 397.67(d) | Requiring or permitting the operation of a motor vehicle containing explosives in Class 1, Divisions 1.1, 1.2, or 1.3 that is not accompanied by a written route plan | Critical |
| 171.15 | Carrier failing to give immediate telephone notice of an incident involving hazardous materials | Critical |
| 171.16 | Carrier failing to make a written report of an incident involving hazardous materials | Critical |
| 172.313(a) | Accepting for transportation or transporting a package containing a poisonous-by-inhalation material that is not marked with the words “Inhalation Hazard” | Acute |
| 172.704(a)(4) | Failing to provide security awareness training | Critical |
| 172.704(a)(5) | Failing to provide in-depth security awareness training | Critical |
| 172.800(b) | Transporting HM without a security plan | Acute |
| 172.800(b) | Transporting HM without a security plan that conforms to Subpart I requirements | Acute |
| 172.800(b) | Failure to adhere to a required security plan | Acute |
| 173.24(b)(1) | Accepting for transportation or transporting a package that has an identifiable release of a hazardous material to the environment | Acute |
| 173.421 | Accepting for transportation or transporting a Class 7 (radioactive) material described, marked, and packaged as a limited quantity when the radiation level on the surface of the package exceeds 0.005mSv/hour (0.5 mrem/hour) | Acute |
| 173.431(a) | Accepting for transportation or transporting in a Type A packaging a greater quantity of Class 7 (radioactive) material than authorized | Acute |
| 173.431(b) | Accepting for transportation or transporting in a Type B packaging a greater quantity of Class 7 (radioactive) material than authorized | Acute |
| 173.441(a) | Accepting for transportation or transporting a package containing Class 7 (radioactive) material with external radiation exceeding allowable limits | Acute |
| 173.442(b) | Accepting for transportation or transporting a package containing Class 7 (radioactive) material when the temperature of the accessible external surface of the loaded package exceeds 50 °C (122 °F) in other than an exclusive use shipment, or 85 °C (185 °F) in an exclusive use shipment | Acute |
| 173.443(a) | Accepting for transportation or transporting a package containing Class 7 (radioactive) material with removable contamination on the external surfaces of the package in excess of permissible limits | Acute |
| 177.800(c) | Failing to instruct a category of employees in hazardous materials regulations | Critical |
| 177.801 | Accepting for transportation or transporting a forbidden material | Acute |
| 177.835(a) | Loading or unloading a Class 1 (explosive) material with the engine running | Acute |
| 177.835(c) | Accepting for transportation or transporting Division 1.1 or 1.2 (explosive) materials in a motor vehicle or combination of vehicles that is not permitted | Acute |
| 177.835(j) | Transferring Division 1.1, 1.2, or 1.3 (explosive) materials between containers or motor vehicles when not permitted | Acute |
| 177.817(a) | Transporting a shipment of hazardous materials not accompanied by a properly prepared shipping paper | Critical |
| 177.817(e) | Failing to maintain proper accessibility of shipping papers | Critical |
| 177.823(a) | Moving a transport vehicle containing hazardous material that is not properly marked or placarded | Critical |
| 177.841(e) | Transporting a package bearing a poison label in the same transport vehicle with material marked or known to be foodstuff, feed, or any edible material intended for consumption by humans or animals unless an exception in § 177.841(e)(i) or (ii) is met | Acute |
| 180.407(a) | Transporting a shipment of hazardous material in cargo tank that has not been inspected or retested in accordance with § 180.407 | Critical |
| 180.407(c) | Failing to periodically test and inspect a cargo tank | Critical |
| 180.415 | Failing to mark a cargo tank which passed an inspection or test required by § 180.407 | Critical |
| 180.417(a)(1) | Failing to retain cargo tank manufacturer's data report certificate and related papers, as required | Critical |
| 180.417(a)(2) | Failing to retain copies of cargo tank manufacturer's certificate and related papers (or alternative report) as required | Critical |
Rated Conditional? See what each violation needs, free
Type your USDOT number and add the violations from your review. RatingFix shows how each one was scored and what FMCSA needs to see fixed. The full upgrade kit (385.17 request letter, corrective action plan, evidence checklist, policies and filing guide) is $499 if you want it.
Next questions
- What does a Conditional safety rating mean?
- How to upgrade a Conditional DOT safety rating
- What's the difference between a compliance review and a safety audit?