What's the difference between a compliance review and a safety audit?

Short answer

A new entrant safety audit checks whether a new carrier has basic safety management controls. It ends in pass or fail and never produces a safety rating (49 CFR 385.317). A compliance review is FMCSA's in-depth onsite investigation. It is the only review that gives you a Satisfactory, Conditional or Unsatisfactory rating.

"Audit," "review" and "investigation" get used loosely, but Part 385 defines two different examinations. Only one of them can give you a safety rating.

Side by side

New entrant safety auditCompliance review
Who gets oneNew interstate carriers during their 18-month new entrant period (385.307)Any carrier: unrated carriers, follow-ups on Conditional or Unsatisfactory carriers, complaints, or a carrier's own request to be re-rated (Appendix B)
PurposeEducational and technical help, plus a check of basic safety management controls (385.309)Decide whether the carrier meets the safety fitness standard in 385.5 (385.3)
What's checkedDriver qualification, duty status, vehicle maintenance, accident register, drug and alcohol testing, using a sample of records (385.311)Hours of service, maintenance and inspection, driver qualification, CDL, financial responsibility, accidents, hazmat and other records (385.3)
ResultPass or fail. No safety rating (385.317)Satisfactory, Conditional or Unsatisfactory, issued within 30 days (385.9)
If it goes badlyCorrective action within 60 days (45 for passenger and hazmat), or registration revoked (385.319)Conditional, or a proposed Unsatisfactory with an operating ban on day 46 or 61 (385.13). May also lead to enforcement (385.3).

The new entrant audit

A new carrier gets a USDOT number and enters an 18-month monitoring period. FMCSA watches its roadside performance and audits it once it has enough records to evaluate, which the rule says is generally at least 3 months of operation (385.307). The 385.3 definition says the audit must happen within 12 months for property carriers and 120 days for passenger carriers. The rule says the audit is generally done at your business premises (385.315).

Passing doesn't make you Satisfactory. You stay Unrated, and when the 18 months end, FMCSA makes your registration permanent (385.333). Failing is covered in what happens if you fail.

The compliance review

Appendix B calls the compliance review an in-depth examination of a carrier's operations. The reviewer goes through driver qualification files, records of duty status, maintenance records and other documents, and cites violations. Those violations are scored as acute or critical across six factors. The factor ratings produce your safety rating. If FMCSA does a compliance review on a new entrant before its audit and issues a rating, the audit is skipped (385.335).

Your own 385.17 upgrade request can be decided on your documents alone (385.17(d)). The rule doesn't require a new review to upgrade.

What usually triggers a compliance review

The 385.3 definition lists requests to change a rating, investigations of potential violations, and complaints. FMCSA's CSA program also uses SMS percentiles to decide which carriers to investigate.

Related questions

Do I get a safety rating after my new entrant audit?

No. 49 CFR 385.317: a safety audit does not result in a safety fitness determination. Most carriers stay Unrated after passing.

How soon after getting a USDOT number is the new entrant audit?

FMCSA generally waits until you have been operating at least 3 months (49 CFR 385.307(b)). The definition in 385.3 says the audit must happen within 12 months for property carriers and 120 days for passenger carriers.

Rated Conditional? See what each violation needs, free

Type your USDOT number and add the violations from your review. RatingFix shows how each one was scored and what FMCSA needs to see fixed. The full upgrade kit (385.17 request letter, corrective action plan, evidence checklist, policies and filing guide) is $499 if you want it.

Start the free breakdown

Next questions

Sources