What happens if you fail a new entrant safety audit?
Short answer
FMCSA must send written notice within 45 days of the audit. You then have 60 days from the notice to fix the deficiencies (45 days for passenger and hazmat carriers), or your new entrant registration is revoked and you are placed out of service. Failing is not a safety rating.
Failing the new entrant audit isn't a safety rating, and it isn't the end. But it starts a short, fixed clock, and missing it costs you your USDOT registration.
How you fail
Under 49 CFR 385.321, you fail if the audit finds a lack of basic safety management controls (Appendix A to Part 385), or if you violate any one of 16 listed regulations. Fourteen of them fail you on a single occurrence. Two need a violation in 51% or more of the records examined.
| # | Regulation | Automatic failure for | Threshold |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 382.115(a)/(b) | No alcohol and/or drug testing program | Single occurrence |
| 2 | 382.201 | Using a driver known to have an alcohol concentration of 0.04 or greater | Single occurrence |
| 3 | 382.211 | Using a driver who refused a required test | Single occurrence |
| 4 | 382.215 | Using a driver known to have tested positive | Single occurrence |
| 5 | 382.305 | No random testing program | Single occurrence |
| 6 | 383.3(a)/383.23(a) | Knowingly using a driver without a valid CDL | Single occurrence |
| 7 | 383.37(b) | Knowingly letting a driver with a disqualified CLP or CDL operate | Single occurrence |
| 8 | 383.51(a) | Knowingly letting a disqualified driver drive a CMV | Single occurrence |
| 9 | 387.7(a) | Operating without required minimum insurance | Single occurrence |
| 10 | 387.31(a) | Operating a passenger vehicle without required minimum insurance | Single occurrence |
| 11 | 391.15(a) | Knowingly using a disqualified driver | Single occurrence |
| 12 | 391.11(b)(4) | Knowingly using a physically unqualified driver | Single occurrence |
| 13 | 395.8(a) | Not requiring a record of duty status | 51%+ of records examined |
| 14 | 396.9(c)(2) | Operating a vehicle declared out of service before repairs | Single occurrence |
| 15 | 396.11(a)(3) | Not correcting out-of-service defects on a driver's DVIR before operating | Single occurrence |
| 16 | 396.17(a) | Using a CMV not periodically (annually) inspected | 51%+ of records examined |
The timeline after a fail
| Step | Most carriers | Passenger (9+ seats for compensation, or 16+) and hazmat carriers |
|---|---|---|
| Written notice from FMCSA | No later than 45 days after the audit (385.319(c)) | |
| Fix the deficiencies by | 60 days from the notice | 45 days from the notice |
| Possible extension | Up to 60 more days for a good-faith effort | Up to 10 more days, only if you've submitted corrective action and FMCSA needs time to review it |
| Registration revoked and out of service | Day 61 (or the day after any extension ends) | Day 46 (or the day after any extension ends) |
Sources: 49 CFR 385.319, 385.323, 385.325.
If FMCSA accepts your corrective action in time, it notifies you in writing that your registration won't be revoked (385.325(a)).
What a corrective action response looks like
Take each violation in the notice in turn. Show the root cause, what you changed, and proof that it's working: the new testing consortium enrollment and random selection records, completed driver qualification files, annual inspection reports, ELD/RODS audit logs, and signed policies. A promise to comply isn't proof.
If you think the audit was wrong
Ask the Field Administrator of your Service Center for an administrative review (385.327). Explain the error and list every disputed issue with supporting documents. File within 15 days of the notice if you want a decision before the out-of-service date. The outer limit is 90 days. FMCSA decides in 45 days (60-day track) or 30 days (45-day track).
Refusing the audit, and reapplying
- If you refuse the audit, FMCSA sends notice. If you don't agree in writing within 10 days, your registration is revoked and you're out of service on day 11 (385.337). Refusal can also bring civil penalties. This is what "new entrant revoked, refusal of audit" on a record means.
- After revocation, you can reapply no sooner than 30 days later. File an updated MCS-150, show the deficiencies are fixed, and restart the 18-month period. For-hire carriers also need to reapply for operating authority (385.329T).
Related questions
Can I get an extension to fix a failed safety audit?
Carriers on the 60-day track can get up to 60 more days if FMCSA sees a good-faith effort. Carriers on the 45-day track can get up to 10 more days, but only if they have already submitted corrective action and FMCSA needs time to evaluate it (49 CFR 385.323).
What does 'new entrant revoked, refusal of audit' mean?
FMCSA revoked the registration because the carrier refused, or didn't respond, to schedule the safety audit. After a written notice, a carrier that doesn't agree within 10 days to permit the audit is revoked and placed out of service on day 11 (49 CFR 385.337).
Can I reapply after my new entrant registration is revoked?
Yes, no sooner than 30 days after the revocation. You file an updated MCS-150, show the deficiencies are fixed, and restart the 18-month monitoring period (49 CFR 385.329T).
Rated Conditional? See what each violation needs, free
Type your USDOT number and add the violations from your review. RatingFix shows how each one was scored and what FMCSA needs to see fixed. The full upgrade kit (385.17 request letter, corrective action plan, evidence checklist, policies and filing guide) is $499 if you want it.
Next questions
- What's the difference between a compliance review and a safety audit?
- How much are FMCSA fines?
- Are CSA scores the same as a safety rating?
Sources
- 49 CFR 385.307, New entrant safety monitoring procedures
- 49 CFR 385.317, Safety audit: safety fitness determination
- 49 CFR 385.319, Safety audit: completion
- 49 CFR 385.321, Safety audit: failure (16 automatic-failure violations)
- 49 CFR 385.323, Safety audit: extensions for corrective action
- 49 CFR 385.325, Safety audit: outcomes of a corrective action notice
- 49 CFR 385.327, Safety audit: administrative review
- 49 CFR 385.329T, Re-application
- 49 CFR 385.337, New entrant refusal to permit safety audit