Should I appeal my safety rating or ask for an upgrade?
Short answer
Ask for an administrative review under 49 CFR 385.15 if FMCSA made a factual or procedural error in your rating. Send an upgrade request under 385.17 if the violations were real and you have fixed them. You can do both, but the review has a 90-day limit and goes to a different office.
Part 385 gives you two separate ways to challenge a rating. They answer different questions. Administrative review asks whether FMCSA got it wrong. An upgrade request says you got it wrong and have fixed it.
Side by side
| Administrative review (385.15) | Upgrade request (385.17) | |
|---|---|---|
| Use it when | FMCSA made an error in assigning the rating | The deficiencies were real and you've corrected them |
| What you send | An explanation of the error, a list of every factual and procedural issue in dispute, and supporting documents | A written description of each corrective action, plus evidence your operations now meet 385.5 and 385.7 |
| Send it to | Assistant Administrator, ATTN: Adjudications Counsel, FMCSA, 1200 New Jersey Ave. SE, Washington, DC 20590-0001 | The FMCSA Service Center for your principal place of business (390.27) |
| Deadline to file | 90 days from the proposed or final rating, or from an upgrade denial. For a proposed Unsatisfactory, file within 15 days to get a decision before the ban. | Any time |
| FMCSA decision time | 30 days (passenger or hazmat) or 45 days (others), for Unsatisfactory ratings only | 30 or 45 days for Unsatisfactory; no deadline for Conditional |
| Possible extras | FMCSA may ask for more data or a conference, and can dismiss the request if you don't provide them (385.15(d)) | FMCSA may use any other relevant information (385.17(d)) |
| Result | Final agency action (385.15(f)) | Upgraded rating, or a denial you can take to administrative review within 90 days (385.17(j)) |
Which one fits
- A violation was miscounted or wasn't yours, for example a driver who wasn't yours or a record FMCSA misread: administrative review.
- The pattern math is wrong, for example a critical violation counted as a pattern when it was under 10% of records checked: administrative review.
- The violations were real, such as missing driver files, no random testing, or late annual inspections: upgrade request. Arguing about real violations rarely helps. Fixing them does.
- A mix: you can file both. 385.15(g) says any carrier may also request a change under 385.17. If the proposed rating has become final, it stays in effect during the administrative review (385.17(j)).
Watch the 90 days
The upgrade route has no deadline, but administrative review does. If you're not sure whether FMCSA erred, decide well before day 90 after the rating notice. After a denied upgrade request, a new 90-day window opens from the denial.
Rated Conditional? See what each violation needs, free
Type your USDOT number and add the violations from your review. RatingFix shows how each one was scored and what FMCSA needs to see fixed. The full upgrade kit (385.17 request letter, corrective action plan, evidence checklist, policies and filing guide) is $499 if you want it.
Next questions
- How to upgrade a Conditional DOT safety rating
- What happens with an Unsatisfactory safety rating?
- How long does it take FMCSA to upgrade a safety rating?